Why is my car knocking so bad?

Predator support for Dodge gas vehicles

Moderator: mikel

Quick
Posts: 1283
Joined: Sun Feb 10, 2008 7:34 am

Re: RE: Why is my car knocking so bad?

Post by Quick »

Chrispy wrote:Thanks for posting, unless you are measuring with a wideband I wouldn't reference the stock PCM readings. Did you raise the rev limit when you raised the shiftpoints? They both need to go up in the stock tune.
PLX Wideband.
No... I didn't raise the rev limiter when I did raised shift points with the "modify stock tune". I didn't know that. and it gave the warning that the rev limiter would be raised. At least I think that's what it said. I didn't really read it carefully since I've seen it so many times raising shift points on the performance tunes. Did it say something like "You NEED to raise the rev limiter"? instead of the message that the rev limiter WILL be raised? I'm running 8r20. Definitely hit the rev limiter pretty hard though :) and that would explain it. Still bumped it after reverting to Original Backup (unmarried and everything). Oh well... no drag racing when I'm on the way to the dealer for service.
I'm thinking there is a fair bit of correction going on after several drives in various load/throttle conditions. I'm going to drive mine for a couple of days and log again. I found out that 91 shell gas up here in Canada is not oxygenated so I'm running a tank of that and will test on the 91 Perf tune. I've added 3% fuel to all ranges to account for the HF cats and will see how it works in the coming days.
You lucky guy. Who knows what we're getting here in the CA Bay Area. I've switched from Chevron to Arco and had my first 1/4 mile with zero knock. Whoo hoo! but who knows what was the cause of that since a number of things were changed/different. More on that below. Searching on the net for BP, Mobil, etc. gas stations here (I know we used to have BP but it may be Arco now) and found out the following when reading about Mobil coming back to the Bay Area. CA regulates the gas coming out of the refineries in the state so they are all supposed to be the same. Who knows how consistent that is or what in the world the requirements are... The same fine eco nuts that forced MTB on us. Anyway, like in Mobil's case, the nearest Mobil/Exxon refinery is in Torance and delivery wouldn't be practical. So the state allows gas stations to get their fuel from any/other companies refinery. Bay Area Mobil stations might get their gas from a Shell refinery and then they add their additives package as it goes in the truck. Arco is owned by BP and the literaterature says they are regularly sampled by BP to meet BP requirements. Whatever that means. I'm hoping it means it's essentially the same gas. They say their methanol like/type oxyginate helps to reduce knock.

I was still getting a couple of bumps of up to 2* KnR. Only in 3rd gear. Bump at about 4400 to 4600 tapering off to about 5300 where it would bump and taper off again. At about 5600 to 5700 it was zero again. So I added 2% more fuel in the mid range and 1% more in the upper range and bingo. I'm not really sure how much I've added total (probably around 5% to 7%) but it doesn't really matter since I'm using a wideband. I initially tried 12.5 across the range, then 12.2 across the range, and now it's pretty much 12.2 in the low rpm range and 12.1-12.0 in the mid and high range. Overall I think I've pulled about 5* of timing... Spark advance is running from as low as 15*, usually 16* or 17* and very occassionally 18*. Not good at all but maybe not horrible. So next thing I'll try is adding 1* in all ranges and see if the KnR comes back, rinse, repeat if the gas is making a difference. Like I said, I pretty much just ran all the Chevron out (3 partial fills totalling about a tank and a quarter so it was getting mixed a bit), outside was a little warmer, and I had just added more fuel. Here's hoping...
2006 Magnum SRT8
AFE Stage II
Mopar Cat Back
185* T-stat
RDP tune by Steve
jtfinklea
Posts: 98
Joined: Sat Mar 08, 2008 1:00 pm

Why is my Car Knocking so bad?

Post by jtfinklea »

To Mike_Levy

My name is Jeff, I have a 2005 300c 5.7 w/ 180* T-Stat, Magnaflo Cat-Back,Billet Oil Catch-can and a Predator running 9r04 91caiOct Tune. Fans set to 180.39 and 183.39.
raised shit points and shift firmness, MDS-off, EGR-off. The car has 77,000 miles and I use all AMSoil, Engine is 0-30 Synthetic w/Ea0 filter, trans-Amsoil-ATF and Amsoil-Sever Gear Lube 75-140.

I would like to exchange my data logs with you, maybe we can help each other figure this knk-st out.

My data logs show no knk-st even at 6k rpm. Not sure about what all to record and how to exchange the logs with you.
Thanks Jeff
Chrispy
Posts: 52
Joined: Fri Dec 28, 2007 11:51 pm

RE: Why is my Car Knocking so bad?

Post by Chrispy »

Ahh I didn't realize you had a wideband in the car my mistake :)

Yup it tells you limiter must be raised. (Diablo does it already in the canned tunes)

I definitely notice a difference with this gas, it's raining today so haven't had a chance to log but will next week. (Supposed to rain all weekend)
2006 300C SRT8
Predator, 185 stat and MF HF cats
User avatar
fordomatic69
Posts: 564
Joined: Mon Feb 11, 2008 3:12 pm

RE: Why is my Car Knocking so bad?

Post by fordomatic69 »

Hey Chrispy, where in Canada you at? Thanks for letting us know that Shell 91 is not Oxygenated in Canada (YET!).... I have a Shell station in Downtown Orangeville, 12Kms from home... SWEET. I was getting a bit of knock on Petro-Can 91 with the 91CAI tune. I tried Sunoco 94 with the 91CAI and 93CAI tunes and I was getting knock at 93CAI because of the ethonol content but it ran well on the 91CAI tune. The only problem is I get .02 cents a litre off at Petro-Canada with my Petro-points card.... :lol: so I put my .02 in this post :lol:
Fordomatic Says:
"I've heard of Vaporware... but I've never actually seen it" :lol:
http://www.twincamlubricants.com - For all your synthetic lubricant needs. Order Online and save over retail.
Chrispy
Posts: 52
Joined: Fri Dec 28, 2007 11:51 pm

RE: Why is my Car Knocking so bad?

Post by Chrispy »

I'm in Burlington Ontario :)

It says on the pump 91 (V-power) has no Eth, 87 has 10% and 89 5%
Cheers,
Chris
2006 300C SRT8
Predator, 185 stat and MF HF cats
User avatar
fordomatic69
Posts: 564
Joined: Mon Feb 11, 2008 3:12 pm

RE: Why is my Car Knocking so bad?

Post by fordomatic69 »

I'm just outside of Orangeville. WOW I am confused on That. With Sunoco, the higher the octane the higher the ethanol content.... Sunoco 94 is 10% eth.... 89 is 5% and I think 87 is 2%. Weird.
Fordomatic Says:
"I've heard of Vaporware... but I've never actually seen it" :lol:
http://www.twincamlubricants.com - For all your synthetic lubricant needs. Order Online and save over retail.
User avatar
Mike_Levy
Posts: 6715
Joined: Fri Oct 26, 2007 8:11 pm
Location: Between Orlando and Tampa

RE: Why is my Car Knocking so bad?

Post by Mike_Levy »

Little update on my car. Swapped out my T-Stat today. Looks like my HyperTech wasn't opening, since even with a 180° stat it was still running over 200°. Put in a THM165 from NAPA and now its running at right around 178-184°. Knock Retard is down to 4.5° ST and 1.5° LT, with a small amount of fuel added on the top end.

Looking at the log, the AFR is dropping and then the KR kicks in. Once the AFR goes back up, the KR is gone. Very strange, because there seems to be no reason for the A/F Ratio to drop. Theres no real pattern to it. On some runs it'll go all the way through the revband and stay constant; On others it will drop at around 3700rpms and stay down until I lift. I'm gonna fill up in the morning and throw in a bottle of NOS Race booster. Even if it doesn't help the KR, the small amount of NitroMethane changes the exhaust sound and sounds wicked. :twisted:
User avatar
fordomatic69
Posts: 564
Joined: Mon Feb 11, 2008 3:12 pm

RE: Why is my Car Knocking so bad?

Post by fordomatic69 »

Hey Mike_Levy, doesn't NOS race booster contain Methyl alcohol? I remember reading in our owner's manual NEVER to use anything containing Methyl alcohol (Fuel injector cleaners, gas line anti-freeze, octane boosters all contain a type of methyl).
Fordomatic Says:
"I've heard of Vaporware... but I've never actually seen it" :lol:
http://www.twincamlubricants.com - For all your synthetic lubricant needs. Order Online and save over retail.
User avatar
Mike_Levy
Posts: 6715
Joined: Fri Oct 26, 2007 8:11 pm
Location: Between Orlando and Tampa

RE: Why is my Car Knocking so bad?

Post by Mike_Levy »

It contains NitroMethane. Been using it for 7 years in a bunch of cars though and have never had an issue, whether in my cheap blown iron block/head GM to my all aluminum BMW. I doubt there will be any issues with using it in my 6.1.
Post Reply

Return to “Predator Dodge Gas”