Another victim of Challenger Throttle Lag after Update

Post questions about your Trinity for your Dodge/Jeep/Chrysler vehicles here.

Moderator: mikel

User avatar
Speedy!
Posts: 48
Joined: Fri Jun 04, 2010 4:32 pm

Another victim of Challenger Throttle Lag after Update

Post by Speedy! »

I recently updated to the Trinity from the Predator and the Trinity needed my CALID updated in order to marry. Ever since I've had a huge lag in my throttle response. AJ has tried several things to solve this issue to no avail. I did some googling and this has happened to quite a few other folks and the consensus is that it's a TSB from Dodge that was a PCM update.

Googling, I found this to be a wide spread issue. It seems some TSB was released (TSB 18-021-09) which best I can tell was a CAL update and this problem was introduced and then superceded by TSB 18-021-09a . Several folks have opened cases with Chrysler which ended up with engineers saying it's normal. Mostly 6 speed cars are the ones who say they have issues, but a few autos as well, and interestingly, a new TSB was released that seemed to fix the problem with the autos, but I don't think anything was ever released for the 6 speeds. The TSB for the Autos was TSB#18-020-11 which states:

Driveability Improvements:
a. Lacks Performance. Some driving conditions can produce circumstances where
some customers may perceive more pedal effort is required to get the Powertrain to
accelerate the vehicle as desired. The PCM calibration for pedal vs. torque
relationship was changed to allow for more torque delivery at less pedal effort/travel.
In accordance with this PCM calibration change, the TCM was re-calibrated to

The issue is shows up as very obvious in data logs.

Here are some threads on the problem that pulled up from a Google search. The first one has the most info and describes the problem I'm having exactly. The issue is most pronounced in 4th gear.

http://www.challengerforumz.com/showthread.php?t=64536

http://www.challengertalk.com/forums/f5 ... lay-43755/

http://www.challengertalk.com/forums/f5 ... nse-37353/

http://www.challengertalk.com/forums/f5 ... 09a-36050/

Here are some screen shots from the data log:

In this screen shot, you can see the pink line is my pedal position and the purple lines are the throttle blade and TPS volts. Notice that the follow each other like they should. There is no issue here. This is cruising along in 4th and easing on and off the throttle 3 separate times.

Image


Now, after the adaptives do whatever they do, this occurs immediately after going WOT and resuming normal driving. Notice how the pink line (me stepping on the throttle) comes quite a bit before the TPS volts and throttle blade respond. This feels like the throttle is dead then the car bucks forward like it tries to catch up. This is cruising along in 4th about 40mph and just easing on and off the throttle three separate times.

Image

Finally, this shows how severe I can make it. This is me just pumping the throttle quickly......notice the pedal is being pressed over and over and over (pink spikes) but the throttle TPS nor the throttle body ever respond at all. Obviously I wouldn't normally drive like this, it was just a test for demonstration.

Image

I can literally pull over, reload the tune in the car, and it's fine again until I go WOT and it instantly returns.

Did anyone ever hear of a TSB solution for this on 6 speed cars? Obviously I can't go to the dealer to get it at this point, but I'm taking the long shot that maybe it's something AJ hasn't heard about but someone else has and he can apply it to my PCM.

We even went as far to have me pull the PCM and mail it to him and he completely reflashed it to a new CALID and we still have the problem, so it's something to do with a CALID update from Dodge.

My only other option is to send the PCM back to him, have it flashed back to the CALID that worked with the Predator, and dump the Trinity, or keep the Trinity as only a data logger and use the Predator to load tunes.

If there's any info out there I'd sure appreciate it. Makes the car a real drag to drive as is and it's a shame because other than this weird throttle problem the tune is outstanding.

AJ's still looking at it, but if there is no solution, I'll have to have the PCM flashed back to the CALID that worked, and go back to the Predator.

Here's video of the problem from another person experiencing the same issue.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=pl ... zjwMCbswdk
Last edited by Speedy! on Thu Mar 01, 2012 9:51 pm, edited 2 times in total.
-Speedy

Image
User avatar
mikel
Posts: 58675
Joined: Tue Jan 16, 2007 1:17 pm
Location: DiabloSport World Headquarters
Contact:

RE: Another victim of Challenger Throttle Lag after Update

Post by mikel »

can you post the tune file that those logs were made with?
Mike Litsch
DiabloSport Brand Manager
Diablo Tech support by phone:
561-908-0040
M-F 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM EST

[email protected]
User avatar
Speedy!
Posts: 48
Joined: Fri Jun 04, 2010 4:32 pm

RE: Another victim of Challenger Throttle Lag after Update

Post by Speedy! »

I can shoot it over in an e-mail, but I believe Johan already has it. Just respond back to my support e-mail I sent this morning and I'll reply with the file.
-Speedy

Image
User avatar
mikel
Posts: 58675
Joined: Tue Jan 16, 2007 1:17 pm
Location: DiabloSport World Headquarters
Contact:

RE: Another victim of Challenger Throttle Lag after Update

Post by mikel »

Johan asked for it, I dont believe he has it, or if he does he does not realize it.
Mike Litsch
DiabloSport Brand Manager
Diablo Tech support by phone:
561-908-0040
M-F 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM EST

[email protected]
User avatar
Speedy!
Posts: 48
Joined: Fri Jun 04, 2010 4:32 pm

RE: Another victim of Challenger Throttle Lag after Update

Post by Speedy! »

Gotcha....just shoot me an e-mail and I'll send it right back at ya: speedy at speedysgarage dot net
-Speedy

Image
User avatar
Ill_Born_SS
Posts: 962
Joined: Fri Aug 08, 2008 4:48 pm

RE: Another victim of Challenger Throttle Lag after Update

Post by Ill_Born_SS »

Just a question if I may, is this car/engine the one in your sig pics, the one with the plastic intake... Have you tried to run a seperate good ground to the throttlebody>engine>chassis
Only one thing to say about my "Diablew" Tune!
" Just Friggin Wicked"
Now with TCM support...
User avatar
mikel
Posts: 58675
Joined: Tue Jan 16, 2007 1:17 pm
Location: DiabloSport World Headquarters
Contact:

RE: Another victim of Challenger Throttle Lag after Update

Post by mikel »

I believe he has a TVS Maggie kit....
Mike Litsch
DiabloSport Brand Manager
Diablo Tech support by phone:
561-908-0040
M-F 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM EST

[email protected]
User avatar
Speedy!
Posts: 48
Joined: Fri Jun 04, 2010 4:32 pm

Re: RE: Another victim of Challenger Throttle Lag after Upda

Post by Speedy! »

mikel wrote:I believe he has a TVS Maggie kit....
This is correct, Magnuson supercharger is on the car.
-Speedy

Image
User avatar
Ill_Born_SS
Posts: 962
Joined: Fri Aug 08, 2008 4:48 pm

RE: Re: RE: Another victim of Challenger Throttle Lag after

Post by Ill_Born_SS »

can you reproduce it with the engine off and key on (live data thru Trinity and Dataviewer, monitor all PIDs of the pedal and throttlebody) then running the pedal through it paces and or doing the same and add a little extra pressure to the throttle blade while it is at 100%
Only one thing to say about my "Diablew" Tune!
" Just Friggin Wicked"
Now with TCM support...
User avatar
Speedy!
Posts: 48
Joined: Fri Jun 04, 2010 4:32 pm

RE: Re: RE: Another victim of Challenger Throttle Lag after

Post by Speedy! »

I haven't tried it without the engine running, but can do that tomorrow after work.

Nutty thing is the car runs PERFECT until some adaptive steps and and ruins my day.
-Speedy

Image
broadfca
Posts: 368
Joined: Mon May 25, 2009 9:06 am

Mopar Badge

Post by broadfca »

Sorry I can't help with your issue, but can you tell me where you got that black front Mopar Badge? Thanks
"El Magnifico" 2009 Challenger SRT8 AutoStick, Corsa Sport Catback Exhaust, Trinity 91 Modified Tune, 180 T-stat, Moroso Catch Can, DMH Electronic Cut Outs, ProTorque Billet Stator 3200 RPM High Stall Torque Converter, K&N, BFG 295/40/20w Rear Tires
User avatar
Ill_Born_SS
Posts: 962
Joined: Fri Aug 08, 2008 4:48 pm

Re: RE: Re: RE: Another victim of Challenger Throttle Lag af

Post by Ill_Born_SS »

Speedy! wrote:I haven't tried it without the engine running, but can do that tomorrow after work.

Nutty thing is the car runs PERFECT until some adaptive steps and and ruins my day.
Have you had a chance to test any?

Where my thought is here... previously you said:
I can literally pull over, reload the tune in the car, and it's fine again until I go WOT and it instantly returns.
and
Now, after the adaptives do whatever they do, this occurs immediately after going WOT and resuming normal driving

These throttlebodies have a built in reset and limp mode capabilities, reset springs and such. ( if the butterfly reaches/passes a certain point, which may not go there engine off, but will reach under WOT )

-Where is the max % tp getting to during WOT? (both engine running and not running)
-Is the 102% engine off key on correct?
-With the key then moved to the run position is the TB resetting itself (before and after symptom appears)
-Is there any codes?
-Have you tried to clear the codes anyway before doing the reflash to correct the throttle descrepincy? ( or even just removing the Neg Batt by itself, and/or both seperately proir to the reflash)
Only one thing to say about my "Diablew" Tune!
" Just Friggin Wicked"
Now with TCM support...
User avatar
mikel
Posts: 58675
Joined: Tue Jan 16, 2007 1:17 pm
Location: DiabloSport World Headquarters
Contact:

RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Another victim of Challenger Throttle La

Post by mikel »

Johan has agreed to look into this some more, but its very complicated and may take some time to compare the factory calibrastions to see what they changed
Mike Litsch
DiabloSport Brand Manager
Diablo Tech support by phone:
561-908-0040
M-F 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM EST

[email protected]
User avatar
Speedy!
Posts: 48
Joined: Fri Jun 04, 2010 4:32 pm

RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Another victim of Challenger Throttle La

Post by Speedy! »

I haven't taken the time to check this without the car running. Based on some conversations with the tuners, this issue is something explicitly introduced by Dodge to the PCM with a TSB update. We all know Chrysler is likely NOT going to fix the problem as they're claiming it was to improve drivability and drive line protection <eye roll>.

If we need this data for general purposes I can take some time to look at it on Saturday, but I don't think it's gonna help solve our problems. There are no codes, and the car is not going in to limp mode or anything like that.

I've seen a couple of new threads pop on the forums with new folks having the problem after allowing one of the Diablo tools to update their car in order to marry the tool. That function is likely using a CAL that has this issue in it, and thus, introduces the new code to the car that causes this lag issue.

Some folks are looking in to fixes for this, but they're gonna have to locate the code in question and either remove it, or replace it with code from a previous CAL that does not have this behavior.

If that's not possible, I plan to pull my PCM and flash it back to the CAL that didn't have this problem and just use my older Predator for tune loads since the Trinity does not work with the older CALID and wants it updated.

Diablo, I know you guys said this would be a large engineering undertaking, but allowing the Trinity to "downgrade" back to a previous CALID may be something you guys want to look in to. Folks are really unhappy with their cars after these updates occur and this issue arises. Being able to downgrade back, would be a life saver here.
-Speedy

Image
broadfca
Posts: 368
Joined: Mon May 25, 2009 9:06 am

Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Another victim of Challenger Throttl

Post by broadfca »

Speedy! wrote:I haven't taken the time to check this without the car running. Based on some conversations with the tuners, this issue is something explicitly introduced by Dodge to the PCM with a TSB update. We all know Chrysler is likely NOT going to fix the problem as they're claiming it was to improve drivability and drive line protection <eye roll>.

If we need this data for general purposes I can take some time to look at it on Saturday, but I don't think it's gonna help solve our problems. There are no codes, and the car is not going in to limp mode or anything like that.

I've seen a couple of new threads pop on the forums with new folks having the problem after allowing one of the Diablo tools to update their car in order to marry the tool. That function is likely using a CAL that has this issue in it, and thus, introduces the new code to the car that causes this lag issue.

Some folks are looking in to fixes for this, but they're gonna have to locate the code in question and either remove it, or replace it with code from a previous CAL that does not have this behavior.

If that's not possible, I plan to pull my PCM and flash it back to the CAL that didn't have this problem and just use my older Predator for tune loads since the Trinity does not work with the older CALID and wants it updated.

Diablo, I know you guys said this would be a large engineering undertaking, but allowing the Trinity to "downgrade" back to a previous CALID may be something you guys want to look in to. Folks are really unhappy with their cars after these updates occur and this issue arises. Being able to downgrade back, would be a life saver here.
Is this inability to downgrade something only on the newer Trinity's. The last time I got my car back from the dealership (4 or 5 months ago), I went to reload the Trinity tune and it said it needed to downgrade. So I did the downgrade and the tune went right in. This may have been something entirely different than your issue, but I just thought I'd throw that out here, My Trinity is an older one. Just ignore this if it doesn't apply.
"El Magnifico" 2009 Challenger SRT8 AutoStick, Corsa Sport Catback Exhaust, Trinity 91 Modified Tune, 180 T-stat, Moroso Catch Can, DMH Electronic Cut Outs, ProTorque Billet Stator 3200 RPM High Stall Torque Converter, K&N, BFG 295/40/20w Rear Tires
Post Reply

Return to “Trinity Dodge Gas”